Find the Best American BBQ in Sydney

There isn’t much better than the smell of some low and slow style barbecued meats, with smoke billowing out the top of a smoker. If you are also a fan of American style BBQ, here are some of the best places you can pick up a pulled pork burger or a brisket box in Sydney.

Hayley pulled together the following list based on the best BBQ joints she has found around Sydney over the last few years searching for Sydney’s best eats while documenting them on her foodie Instagram account, @thesydneyfoodhunt! With American style BBQ being one of my all-time favourite feeds, you can trust me when I say the following BBQ joints are some of the best Sydney offers!  

Where to find the best American BBQ in Sydney

In no particular order, these are my favourite places to feast on some American BBQ in Sydney!  

BlackBear BBQ

The team at BlackBear BBQ have developed a bit of a cult following over the years, after establishing an impressive total of three locations across Sydney, all while travelling to different markets and festivals in their food truck to put happy faces and full bellies on as many Sydneysiders as possible!  

American BBQ in Sydney from BlackBear

They have developed from being a couple of mates cooking up meat on a backyard smoker for fun, to now being a widely popular establishment with not only restaurant meals, but having their own butcher shop selling the finest quality cuts, and holding their own BBQ masterclasses – so you can trust they know what they’re doing!  

Must try: The Hungry Bear Box (Taste little bit of everything they have on offer!) or at breakfast add the Brisket beans to your order.

Where: Barbeque restaurants in Vineyard, Blacktown, Wetherill Park and at events and festivals

Smoky Sue’s

Smoky Sue’s is a relatively new kid on the block, and with two locations, they are definitely standing their ground! Smoky Sue’s mantra is “barbecue done different,” and we certainly aren’t complaining! Whatever they are doing, they certainly need to keep doing it!  

Pictured below is the ‘Ribby McRib Face Burger,’ and the picture really speaks for itself! This $34 burger is their iconic beef short rib burger with slaw, pickles, cheese and BBQ sauce! The best part (other than eating it, of course) is that the burger still comes with the rib bone inside, so you have to do the rib pull yourself! (Check out my Instagram for my attempt at it!). They also do delicious sweet potato fries.

Must try: The Ribby McRib Face Burger, their range of fresh sodas!  

Where: 737 Anzac Parade, Maroubra and 148 Station St, Penrith 

2 Smokin’ Arabs

The guys at 2 Smokin’ Arabs run an ever so successful food truck which travels around Sydney.  They have some pretty unique, tasty flavours that you won’t find at any of the other BBQ joints, which is what makes them so special.  

2 Smokin’ Arabs also strictly barbecue with only 100% wagyu 9+, which is a rarity in the BBQ game, so by hitting up their food truck, you know you are getting the best quality! All the meat served is halal.

Must try: The TRUFF Burger with Wagyu 9+ patty and American jack cheese

Where: Primarily based in Punchbowl, but food truck travels! Check their Facebook for the latest news.

Surly’s American Tavern

If you are looking for something a bit closer to the Sydney CBD, and that has the fit out to match the food – it’s Surly’s that you are going to want to try for classic American cuisine.  

All the American classics served at this ripper American BBQ restaurant

Surly’s is ‌in Surry Hills and is constantly busy, with people from all over Sydney, and travellers alike, coming to try their low and slow style American BBQ, accompanied by their traditional American sides.  

Surly’s currently has an All You Can Eat American BBQ deal, where for just $50 you can sit with your friends and devour as much beef brisket, pulled pork, smoked chicken thighs, hot link sausage and chicken wings as your heart desires! Don’t forget that all the southern essentials like fries, slaw, onions, pickles and cornbread are included too! 

Must try: 18 hour dry rubbed smoked brisket and the traditional American cornbread! 

Where: 182 Campbell St, Surry Hills NSW

Once you have your fill of BBQ check out our guide to Sydney’s Best Desserts

Smokin’ Hot and Saucy

This is a BBQ joint where they really live up to their name! Smokin’ Hot and Saucy have teamed up with Penrith local brewing company Rusty Penny Brewing Co, and opened a beer and BBQ lover’s delight!  

Located inside Rusty Penny’s brewing warehouse, you can truly be transported to the heart of Texas, with American football and basketball on the big screen, craft beer in hand, and a hearty plates of American BBQ deliciousness on the way. Buffalo wings and local boutique beers, anyone?

Make sure you don’t leave without purchasing a bottle of one of their signature sauces to take home!  

Must try: The Smoked Chicken Pieces, the Raspberry Sweet and Spicy Texan Jam (with the pulled pork!)  

Where: 137 Coreen Ave, Penrith NSW

Fire and Brimstone Barbecue

Located inside Castle Hill’s popular pub – The Hillside Hotel, you are guaranteed to have a great time with a night spent at Fire and Brimstone!  

Fire and Brimstone BBQ Restaurant in Sydney
Fire and Brimstone

These guys have really upped their BBQ game, offering a variety of different ways to enjoy their smoked meats. On Friday and Saturday nights, you can enjoy Bottomless Beer and BBQ for 2  hours for just $79pp.  

If you are feeling a little bit fancy, you can attend one of their ‘Glenlivet 5 Course Pairing Dinners’, which involves a variety of courses including pulled pork sliders, beef brisket, lamb shoulder and more – each paired with a Glenlivet bourbon!  

Must try: Chicken Maryland or the Smashed Cheeseburger!  

Where: 1/273 Old Northern Rd, Castle Hill  

Smokin’ Als BBQ

Smokin’ Als is a Halal BBQ joint based in Rockdale that does the absolute lot! They’re serving up  smoked meats, burgers, hot dogs, wings, tenders, loaded fries and all the sides you can think of!  

All the meat smoked in house

My personal favourites from Smokin’ Als is the Fresh Philly Hoagie – Black Angus, onions,  provolone cheese and cheese sauce on a hoagie roll, the Big Apple Hot Dog – House made hotdog with mustard, pickles, onion and apple slaw and their good-old, classic – pulled beef!  

If you have room after your meaty meal, Smokin’ Als serves up some delicious desserts as well! You can choose from a giant choc chip cookie, a loaded brownie, a hot cinnamon Hershey’s  donut (very American) – or a try a little bit of each!  

Must try: Everything mentioned above, plus the Smoked Corn on the Cob with chipotle mayo butter, smokey salt and Grana Padana cheese!  

Where: 91 Railway St, Rockdale

NOLA Smokehouse and Bar

NOLA isn’t quite like all the other BBQ joints on this list, they have taken American BBQ, and fine dining – and mashed them together to create the wonderful NOLA Smokehouse in the heart of Sydney, at Barangaroo.  

Nola Barangaroo American BBQ will transport you to New Orleans

NOLA stands for New Orleans, Louisiana – and it’s not just the name that this restaurant has taken inspiration from the southern state for! NOLA aims to bring its visitors a true taste of the heart of soul that New Orleans Louisiana flavours offer.

NOLA offers a contemporary approach to BBQ, includes the soul food staples, while offering a wide selection of American whiskeys to pair, to create an authentic American smokehouse feel. So, if you really feel like some delicious BBQ, but also feel like dressing up and going to the city – NOLA is your best friend!  

Must try: Apple Cider Pulled Pork, Seared Steak Tartare 

Where: Level 1, One International Towers Sydney, Cnr Barangaroo Ave & Shipwright Walk, Barangaroo South

Other spots to try for the best American BBQ Sydney can offer

We still have a few spots on our wish list, American Barbecue lovers might like to beat us to it and visit some of these

  • Vic’s Meat Market at Sydney Fish Market
  • The Oxford Hotel
  • L & P Quality Meats

American BBQ has gotten quite popular with Sydney-siders, and this is not an exhaustive list! Let us know your favourite BBQ joints in the comments below!

About the author: Western Sydney based creator, Hayley Tighe, runs The Sydney Food Hunt and aims to source and highlight the best food and drink across Greater Sydney to share with other Sydneysiders and visitors on Instagram.

Main image: NOLA Barangaroo Credit: Destination NSW

Leave a comment